CORRECTIONS INTERNATIONALLY
US unlike most other countries: Prefers imprisonment |
|
Foreign systems do not adhere to
any single punishment philosophy (rehabilition, general and specific deterrence incapacitation) |
|
Currently: Reassessment concerning
the treatment of sex offenders Prompted by cases involving serious and repeat offenders and lack of cross-border information sharing |
Responses:
Call for European wide linking of DNA databases
Long term incarceration past sentence completion for
protection of society
(Lebenslang mit anschließender Sicherheitsverwahrung)
PENALTY CATEGORIES OR TYPES OF PUNISHMENT
Financial-Fine
Day Fines make up half or more of penalties in property and violent crimes in
Sweden and Germany
Corporal-Caning, flogging, etc
Capital-execution (hanging, stoning, lethal injection, beheading)
US: 38 states federal government
Methods: Lethal Injection, Electrocution, Lethal Gas, Firing Squad, and Hanging
Lethan Injection with 20 states having additional choices (menus?)
Nebraska: Electrocution only method
2003: 1,146 executions in 28 countries.
88% in five PRC (726), Iran (108), U.S.(65), Vietnam (64), Saudi Arabia (52).
(Some indication that executions in PRC more than ten times greater than reported)
Stoning (above) in Iran
Photo courtesy of http://iranvajahan.net/english/index.shtml
Custodial-incarceration up to and including life imprisonment
United Nations Minimum Standards for detaining or holding prisoners
No enforcement mechanism for standards and not all countries adhere to it
Standards also subject to interpretation
Non custodial-probation, community service, etc.
Corrections Function typically under the Justice Ministry
Austria-interesting example of totally privatized probation/parole function
http://www.bmj.gv.at/justiz/content.php?nav=53
Western countries other than U.S. and U.K.:
Corrections centralized function usually under Department or Ministry of Justice
Includes probation and parole
Interesting provisions for parole in Belgium below (Will be translated in class)
VI. Libération conditionnelle
VI.1. Conditions pour bénéficier de la libération conditionnelle
Base légale: conditions de temps article 2, 1° LLC; conditions de fond article 2, 2° et 3° LLC
Pour bénéficier d’une libération conditionnelle, les condamnés primaires doivent avoir subi 1/3 de la peine ou 10 ans s’ils ont été condamnés à perpétuité. Ceux qui se trouvent en état de récidive légale doivent avoir subi 2/3 de la peine ou quatorze ans s’ils se trouvent en état de récidive légale.
Le condamné doit en outre pouvoir présenter, avec l'aide des services compétents, un plan de reclassement duquel apparaissent sa volonté et son effort de réinsertion.
Il ne peut enfin exister aucune contre-indication impliquant un risque
sérieux pour la société ou faisant raisonnablement obstacle
aux conditions de réinsertion sociale du condamné. Ces contre-indications
se rapportent :
a. aux possibilités de reclassement du condamné ;
b. à sa personnalité ;
c. à son comportement pendant la détention ;
d. au risque de voir le condamné commettre de nouveaux faits constitutifs
d’infractions ;
e. à l'attitude du condamné à l'égard des victimes
des infractions qui ont donné lieu à sa condamnation.
http://www.moniteur.be/index_fr.htm
VI.5. Décision de rejet d'une proposition de LC
Toutes les décisions, y compris les décisions de rejet, doivent être motivées.
En cas de rejet, la Commission fixe la date à partir de laquelle
le dossier peut être réexaminé par la conférence
du personnel. Ce délai ne peut excéder 6 mois pour les peines
correctionnelles dont le total n’excède pas 5 ans et est de 1 an
maximum pour les peines criminelles ou lorsque le total des peines correctionnelles
est supérieur à 5 ans.
Visit the |
http://www.gendarmeria.cl/rehabilitacion/main-rehab-2a.htm
Academy for "vigilantes" 1 year
Academy for "oficiales" 2 years
Entry standards similar to Carabineros except for "oficiales"
Review the Ley Orgánica de Gendarmería
and the Reglamento
de Establecimientos Penitenciarios
Will translate highlights during lecture.
Compare to California Department of Corrections
Promotional Requirements for Sergeant
Testing: The written test is designed to evaluate candidates’ skills in the areas of grammar, spelling, punctuation, reading comprehension, and basic mathematics. WRITTEN TEST (PASS/FAIL)
BASIC CORRECTIONAL OFFICER ACADEMY (BCOA) Candidates receiving and accepting assignments as COs must complete a 16-week, comprehensive training program at the BCOA located in Galt, a suburb of Sacramento. Candidates are encouraged to refresh/develop their analytical, writing and memory retention skills; maintain their physical fitness; and take a weapons course, prior to reporting to the BCOA. Upon successful completion of the BCOA, COs report directly to their assigned institution. Failure to pass the BCOA will result in rejection from the CO classification.
http://www.corr.ca.gov/SelectionsStandards/PDFFiles/COBulletin.pdf
LOCATION OF CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTIONS:
Population Centers (Europe)
Dept of Correctional Services (South Africa)
Also review articles on Corruption in Corrections
Germany:
Map of California Correctional Institutions
Important Concepts/Information:
Qualified applicants can enter a correctional career in many foreign countries at two or more rank levels.
Day fines are very common in Europe and are based on the offender's income per day
The U.S. is on the list of top five countries for executions
Corporal punishment, i.e. caning, is most common in Islamic countries
Stoning is still practiced in Iran
Fines instead of incarceration for criminal offenses are more common in European countries than in the U.S.
The entry and training standards for correctional personnel in Chile is very high compared to the U.S.
Belgian offenders are eligible for parole after serving 1/3 of their sentence or 10 years of a life sentence.
Offenders rejected for parole can re-apply within six months if serving a sentence of 5 years or less, or within 1 year if serving a sentence of more than 5 years.